welcome

SHL Discord

Welcome to the Simulation Hockey League!

The SHL is a hockey player sim league that has been running strong for over thirty seasons in its current iteration! Through the use of Simon T. Hockey Simulator and a unique progression system, the SHL promises to be just what you're looking for and more!
staff
League Management
expand/close

OWNERS:
Leafs4ever
jkrever
Spangle
Trill

COMMISSIONERS:
Eggy216

SMJHL COMMISSIONERS:
Storm
ztevans
Rabidsponge21

HEAD OFFICE:
CRUTCHFIELD
Formx
prettyburn
ArGarBarGar
Avakael
Copenhagen


SHL GENERAL MANAGERS
Buffalo Stampede:
ThatDamnWalrus
Tomen

Hamilton Steelhawks:
ThatDamnMcJesus
Gooney

Manhattan Rage:
Muerto


Minnesota Chiefs:
Baelor Swift
Andybj

New England Wolfpack:
Eggy216
Toivo

Toronto North Stars:
Cynthia
Winter is Coming

West Kendall Platoon:
Bojo
enigmatic

Calgary Dragons:
Steelhead77
c00kies

Edmonton Blizzard:
karlssens


Los Angeles Panthers:
Wasty
vbottas17

Portland Admirals:
Wally
tweedledunn

Seattle Riot:
mpclardy
ckroyal92
Texas Renegades:
Allen
Durden

Winnipeg Jets:
Nereus
ztevans

SMJHL GENERAL MANAGERS:
Detroit Falcons:
WannabeFinn
Avakael

Halifax Raiders:
NYRangers3061
bozzz

Montreal Militia:
Grapehead
Raven

St. Louis Scarecrows:
TML99
JKortesi81

Colorado Mammoths:
jjaybs
InciteHysteria

Kelowna Knights:
ej27
Jenny

Prince George Firebirds:
artermis
Symmetrik

Vancouver Whalers:
Kaisonious
Winter Is Coming
twitter
news
The Simulation Hockey League's 36th Season is currently underway!

Congratulations to the Toronto North Stars for winning the Season 35 Challenge Cup, and the Vancouver Whalers for winning the Season 35 Four Star Cup!
 

Pages: (10) 1 2 3 ... Last » ( Go to first unread post ) .reply    .new topic    .new poll   

» Top 50/10 Skaters/Goaltenders of All Time, Full Voting Thread
ArGarBarGar
 Posted: Jun 12 2017, 02:41 PM
.quote   



Head Office
Posts: 15367
Joined: 2-September 14
Member ID: 1352
Rep: 165 pts

Offline


N/A


Top 50/10 SHL Skaters/Goaltenders of All Time!


After 15 seasons of the Top 100 SHL Players of Today, I have decided to start a voting thread to determine the top players to ever play the game.

I have begun by separating the voting into the top 50 skaters and top 10 goaltenders, and will be including what I believe to be the top-10 skaters and top-5 goaltenders of all time into the first ballot. You as a user will vote in each category who is 1-50/1-10 of the current block of players, and after a certain time whoever has the most votes will be named 1-50/1-10, and we will move to the next number. I will also ask that you nominate a player to be added to the list and be voted on.

Below is the template I would like you to use for each vote.

CODE
[u][b]Skater #9:[/b][/u]


[u][b]Goaltender #9:[/b][/u]


[u][b]Skater+Goaltender to be added for Poll #10:[/b][/u]




Now let us get started!

Top 50 Skaters of All Time!
1. C - (S1) Ron Mexico
2. D - (S10) Chris Partlow
3. C - (S8) Joe McKeil
4. D - (S8) Darian Scherbluk
5. C- (S8) Chris McZehrl
6. D - (S6) Jason Due
7. C - (S8) Taylor McDavid
8. C - (S7) David Winter
9.

Top 10 Goaltenders of All Time!
1. (S13) Jakub Aittokallio
2. (S5) John McBride
3. (S13) Lauris Prikulis
4. (S14) Jordin FourFour
5. (S20) Jakob Tanner
6. (S1) Ryan Jesster
7. (S2) Mike Honcho
8. (S11) Mike Verminski
9.



League of Accomplished Players (Updated for S34)
Use above for reference



Skater Nominees
C - Reggie Williams
707 GP | 188 G | 323 A | 511 P
1x Jeff Dar Trophy (S12)
1x Damian Littleton Trophy (S8)
1x Sarmad Khan Trophy (S12)
1x Jay McDonald Trophy (S12)
5x Challenge Cup (S8, S9, S12, S15, S16)
Ryan Jesster Nominee (S6)
4x Jeff Dar Nominee (S8, S9, S11)
1x Ron Mexico Nominee (S12)

C- Carter O'Callahan
809 GP | 268 G | 385 A | 653 P
1x 1st All-Star Team (S22)
1x 2nd All-Star Team (S21)
2x 3rd All-Star Team (S18, S20)
1x Ron Mexico Trophy (S19)
2x Turd Ferguson Trophy (S18, S19)
1x Jeff Dar Trophy (S19)
2x Damian Littleton Trophy (S15, S16)
1x Sarmad Khan Trophy (S19)
1x Sergei Karpotsov Trophy (S19)
1x Jay McDonald Trophy (S19)
1x Challenge Cup (S23)
Ryan Jesster Nominee (S14)
2x Ron Mexico Nominee (S15, S21)
4x Jeff Dar Nominee (S18, S20, S21, S22)

C - Sarmad Khan
290 GP | 81 G | 143 A | 322 P*
1x Ron Mexico Trophy (S2)
1x Sarmad Khan Trophy (S2)
2x Challenge Cup (S2, S5)

LW - Kain Webb
554 GP | 248 G | 318 A | 566 P
Ryan Jesster Trophy (S5)
1x Ron Mexico Trophy (S12)
1x Sarmad Khan Trophy (S6)
3x Jay McDonald Trophy (S6, S12, S13)
1x Anton Razov Trophy (S9)
2x Challenge Cup (S8, S9)
2x Ron Mexico Nominee (S6, S14)

LW - Jeff Dar
283 GP | 110 G | 104 A | 258 P*
3x Jeff Dar Trophy (S1, S5, S6)
1x Jay McDonald Trophy (S6)
2x Damian Littleton Nominee (S6, S8)
1x Challenge Cup (S6)

RW - Elias Armia
498 GP | 211 G | 297 A | 508 P
2x Ron Mexico Trophy (S11, S13)
Ryan Jesster Trophy (S7)
1x Damian Littleton Trophy (S12)
1x Sarmad Khan Trophy (S11)
2x Sergei Karpotsov Trophy (S11, S13)
1x Jay McDonald Trophy (S8)
1x Challenge Cup (S14)
4x Damian Littleton Nominee (S9, S14, S15, S16)
1x Jeff Dar Nominee (S11)

RW - Theo Kane
704 GP | 281 G | 328 A | 609 P
2x 1st All-Star Team (S29, S33)
1x 2nd All-Star Team (S27)
1x 3rd All-Star Team (S31)
2x Ron Mexico Trophy (S29, S33)
2x Jeff Dar Trophy (S29, S33)
2x Sarmad Khan Trophy (S29, S33)
1x Anton Razov Trophy (S28)
1x Sergei Karpotsov Trophy (S29)
2x Jay McDonald Trophy (S29, S33)
1x Challenge Cup (S28)
Aidan Richan Nominee (S29)

D - Scott Stevens
280 GP | 17 G | 114 A | 152 P*
2x Scott Stevens Trophy (S5, S8)
1x Challenge Cup (S6)
1x Scott Stevens Nominee (S6)

D - Alonzo Garbanzo
708 GP | 113 G | 456 A | 609 P
5x 1st All-Star Team (S26, S27, S30, S31, S33)
2x 2nd All-Star Team (S24, S34)
2x 3rd All-Star Team (S29, S32)
3x Scott Stevens Trophy (S27, S31, S33)
1x Ron Mexico Trophy (S27)
Aidan Richan Trophy (S24)
3x Scott Stevens Nominee (S24, S26, S30)
1x Ron Mexico Nominee (S31)
2x Damian Littleton Nominee (S26, S31)

D - Willie Weber
1015 GP | 188 G | 450 A | 638 P
1x 1st All-Star Team (S22)
3x 2nd All-Star Team (S18, S20, S21)
1x 3rd All-Star Team (S25)
1x Scott Stevens Trophy (S15)
3x Challenge Cup (S15, S16, S23)
Ryan Jesster Nominee (S9)
Aidan Richan Nominee (S14)
3x Scott Stevens Nominee (S14, S18, S22)

Goaltender Nominees
Tom Corcoran
216-120-35 | .905 sv% | 2.48 GAA
1x John McBride Trophy (S13)
1x Sarmad Khan Trophy (S13)
1x Mike Honcho Trophy (S10)
1x Challenge Cup (S13)
3x John McBride Nominee (S7, S10, S11)
Aidan Richan Nominee (S13)
1x Ron Mexico Nominee (S13)

C.J. James
200-172-34 | .904 sv% | 2.415 GAA
2x 2nd All-Star Team (S23, S24)
2x 3rd All-Star Team (S17, S25)
1x Challenge Cup (S22)
3x John McBride Nominee (S17, S23, S24)

Jackson Weekes
206-119-40 | .910 sv% | 2.462 GAA
1x 1st All-Star Team (S24)
2x 2nd All-Star Team (S25, S27)
1x 3rd All-Star Team (S23)
1x Ron Mexico Trophy (S24)
1x John McBride Trophy (S24)
1x Sarmad Khan Trophy (S24)
1x Mike Honcho Trophy (S24)
2x John McBride Nominee (S23, S28)
Aidan Richan Nominee (S24)

Brandon Sawyer
243-157-38 | .904 sv% | 2.517 GAA
2x Anton Razov Trophy (S6, S10)
2x Challenge Cup (S10, S12)
2x John McBride Nominee (S6, S8)

Edwin Ask
302-170-42 | .904 sv% | 2.391 GAA
1x 3rd All-Star Team (S16)
1x John McBride Trophy (S16)
2x Mike Honcho Trophy (S16, S19)
1x Challenge Cup (S10)
1x John McBride Nominee (S14)

--------------------
The Road Lead All Defensemen:
Goals | 6th (7 to 5th)
Assists | 2nd (42 to 1st)
Hits | 2nd (1021 to 1st)
Blocked Shots | All Time Blocked Shots Leader (1324)
Points | 2nd (84 to 1st)
user posted image
"League of Accomplished Players"
Player Profile | Update Thread
.pm   
^
JumpierPegasus
 Posted: Jun 12 2017, 04:48 PM
.quote   

stupid idiot

Coach
Posts: 13305
Joined: 22-December 11
Member ID: 41
Rep: 291 pts

Offline


N/A


Skater #1: Ron Mexico (Partlow/McKeil close #2/3 for me, but he will always be the original GOAT)

Goaltender #1: John McBride

Skater/Goaltender to be added for Poll #2: Elias Armia/Mike Honcho

This post has been edited by JumpierPegasus: Jun 12 2017, 04:53 PM

--------------------
user posted image

user posted image








.pm   
^
ArGarBarGar
 Posted: Jun 12 2017, 04:52 PM
.quote   



Head Office
Posts: 15367
Joined: 2-September 14
Member ID: 1352
Rep: 165 pts

Offline


N/A


QUOTE (JumpierPegasus @ Jun 12 2017, 04:48 PM)
Skater #1: Ron Mexico (Partlow/McKeil close #2/3 for me, but he will always be the original GOAT)

Goaltender #1: John McBride

Skater/Goaltender to be added for Poll #2: Elias Armia

Please pick both a skater and goaltender to be added. Sorry if that wasn't clear, earlier.

--------------------
The Road Lead All Defensemen:
Goals | 6th (7 to 5th)
Assists | 2nd (42 to 1st)
Hits | 2nd (1021 to 1st)
Blocked Shots | All Time Blocked Shots Leader (1324)
Points | 2nd (84 to 1st)
user posted image
"League of Accomplished Players"
Player Profile | Update Thread
.pm   
^
JumpierPegasus
 Posted: Jun 12 2017, 04:54 PM
.quote   

stupid idiot

Coach
Posts: 13305
Joined: 22-December 11
Member ID: 41
Rep: 291 pts

Offline


N/A


QUOTE (ArGarBarGar @ Jun 12 2017, 01:52 PM)

Please pick both a skater and goaltender to be added. Sorry if that wasn't clear, earlier.

Funny enough had a goalie first, changed it to a skater so at least I had both at some point http://i.imgur.com/5wrNzrG.gif

There is a particular goalie who could probably be nominated at some point in the discussions, but I'm assuming [REDACTED] isn't going to be in any of these polls? http://www.planetsmilies.com/smilies/confused/confused0060.gif

--------------------
user posted image

user posted image








.pm   
^
RomanesEuntDomus
 Posted: Jun 12 2017, 04:55 PM
.quote   

S10 Challenge Cup Champion

SHL GM
Posts: 15117
Joined: 23-December 11
Member ID: 86
Rep: 256 pts

Offline


N/A


Skater #1: Joe McKeil

Goaltender #1: Jakub Aittokallio

Skater/Goaltender to be added for Poll #2: Carter O'Callahan / Brandon Sawyer

--------------------
>Player Page<

user posted image

.pm   
^
ThatDamnWalrus
 Posted: Jun 12 2017, 05:03 PM
.quote   

Make Buffalo Great Again

SHL GM
Posts: 6708
Joined: 30-June 14
Member ID: 1245
Rep: 1003 pts

Offline

N/A
N/A


Skater #1: David Winter

Goaltender #1: Jakub Aittokallio

Skater/Goaltender to be added for Poll #2: Jordin FourFour

--------------------

user posted image


Player Page II Update Thread || Signatures

user posted image user posted image user posted image

.pm   
^
FourFour
 Posted: Jun 12 2017, 05:20 PM
.quote   

S20, S21 Challenge Cup Champion

SMJHL GM
Posts: 23210
Joined: 30-March 13
Member ID: 802
Rep: 50 pts

Offline


N/A


QUOTE (JumpierPegasus @ Jun 12 2017, 02:54 PM)

Funny enough had a goalie first, changed it to a skater so at least I had both at some point http://i.imgur.com/5wrNzrG.gif

There is a particular goalie who could probably be nominated at some point in the discussions, but I'm assuming [REDACTED] isn't going to be in any of these polls?  http://www.planetsmilies.com/smilies/confused/confused0060.gif

^^^^^

--------------------
Jordin FourFour Jr. Updates

user posted image
user posted image
Jordin FourFour Player Alumni: user posted imageuser posted imageuser posted imageuser posted imageuser posted imageuser posted imageuser posted imageuser posted image
Jordin FourFour GM Alumni:user posted imageuser posted imageuser posted image


.pm   
^
ArGarBarGar
 Posted: Jun 12 2017, 05:34 PM
.quote   



Head Office
Posts: 15367
Joined: 2-September 14
Member ID: 1352
Rep: 165 pts

Offline


N/A


QUOTE (JumpierPegasus @ Jun 12 2017, 04:54 PM)

Funny enough had a goalie first, changed it to a skater so at least I had both at some point http://i.imgur.com/5wrNzrG.gif

There is a particular goalie who could probably be nominated at some point in the discussions, but I'm assuming [REDACTED] isn't going to be in any of these polls?  http://www.planetsmilies.com/smilies/confused/confused0060.gif

I think to avoid confusion I would remove them from the discussion.

--------------------
The Road Lead All Defensemen:
Goals | 6th (7 to 5th)
Assists | 2nd (42 to 1st)
Hits | 2nd (1021 to 1st)
Blocked Shots | All Time Blocked Shots Leader (1324)
Points | 2nd (84 to 1st)
user posted image
"League of Accomplished Players"
Player Profile | Update Thread
.pm   
^

mpclardy
 Posted: Jun 12 2017, 05:37 PM
.quote   

Somehow a GM

SHL GM
Posts: 20455
Joined: 31-August 14
Member ID: 1322
Rep: 1 pts

Offline

N/A
N/A


Skater #1: Chris Partlow


Goaltender #1: Lauris Prikulis


Skater+Goaltender to be added for Poll #2: Vidrik Onoprienko / Dustin Rose

--------------------
user posted image\\\\\user posted image/////user posted image\\\\\user posted image/////user posted image
user posted image
Proud Affiliate: user posted image user posted image user posted image
Nikitin's Affiliates: user posted image user posted image user posted image user posted image
QUOTE (gorlab @ May 26 2015, 07:42 PM)
miss u clardy
QUOTE (artermis @ Apr 6 2017, 06:35 AM)
Thank you very much for the kind words, it means a lot coming from you.
QUOTE (probablydrunk @ May 10 2017, 07:33 PM)
I'd take 3 clardys to one Mac, maybe even 4
QUOTE (ztevans @ Jun 6 2017, 12:37 PM)
#ClardyForCoGM


.pm   
^
ArGarBarGar
 Posted: Jun 12 2017, 06:07 PM
.quote   



Head Office
Posts: 15367
Joined: 2-September 14
Member ID: 1352
Rep: 165 pts

Offline


N/A


Thinking keeping each rank up for 3 days, then tabulating votes and moving on.

Gives us about two a week.

--------------------
The Road Lead All Defensemen:
Goals | 6th (7 to 5th)
Assists | 2nd (42 to 1st)
Hits | 2nd (1021 to 1st)
Blocked Shots | All Time Blocked Shots Leader (1324)
Points | 2nd (84 to 1st)
user posted image
"League of Accomplished Players"
Player Profile | Update Thread
.pm   
^
Allegiant
 Posted: Jun 12 2017, 06:07 PM
.quote   

S3 and S28 Challenge Cup Champion

Coach
Posts: 3815
Joined: 22-April 15
Member ID: 1654
Rep: 43 pts

Offline


N/A


Skater #1: Chris Partlow

Goaltender #1: Jakub Aittokallio

Skater+Goaltender to be added for Poll #2: Jordin FourFour/Jay McDonald

--------------------
user posted image



Player Page // Signature by Crutchfield

Affiliate of: user posted image user posted image user posted image
.pm   
^
ArGarBarGar
 Posted: Jun 12 2017, 06:24 PM
.quote   



Head Office
Posts: 15367
Joined: 2-September 14
Member ID: 1352
Rep: 165 pts

Offline


N/A


QUOTE (ThatDamnWalrus @ Jun 12 2017, 05:03 PM)
Skater #1: David Winter

Goaltender #1: Jakub Aittokallio

Skater/Goaltender to be added for Poll #2: Jordin FourFour

Need to nominate a skater, also.

--------------------
The Road Lead All Defensemen:
Goals | 6th (7 to 5th)
Assists | 2nd (42 to 1st)
Hits | 2nd (1021 to 1st)
Blocked Shots | All Time Blocked Shots Leader (1324)
Points | 2nd (84 to 1st)
user posted image
"League of Accomplished Players"
Player Profile | Update Thread
.pm   
^
r1c3bowl22
 Posted: Jun 12 2017, 07:36 PM
.quote   

Sugar Tits

Coach
Posts: 20436
Joined: 7-July 14
Member ID: 1286
Rep: 118 pts

Offline

N/A
N/A


Skater #1: Chris Partlow


Goaltender #1: Lauris Prikulis


Skater+Goaltender to be added for Poll #2: Carter O'Callaghan/Jordin FourFour

Also, ArGarBarGar, I know it hasn't been updated in a while, but whenever you get around to it, I'm listed in that file twice lol

--------------------
Your mental health is just as important as your physical health. Please take care of it. Here are some helpful links just in case.

Good2Talk - 1-866-925-5454
Kid's Help Phone - 1-800-668-6868
Mental Health Hotline Ontario - 1-866-531-2600


If you have the contact info to your local mental help centres, let me know!
--------------------
Words to live by:

- It's okay to not be okay, it'll get better.
- Do you make jokes to make people laugh, or to make people think you're funny?
Player Page|Player Updates
Proud affiliate of: user posted imageuser posted imageuser posted imageuser posted imageuser posted imageuser posted imageuser posted image

.pm   
^
ArGarBarGar
 Posted: Jun 12 2017, 07:42 PM
.quote   



Head Office
Posts: 15367
Joined: 2-September 14
Member ID: 1352
Rep: 165 pts

Offline


N/A


QUOTE (r1c3bowl22 @ Jun 12 2017, 07:36 PM)
Skater #1: Chris Partlow


Goaltender #1: Lauris Prikulis


Skater+Goaltender to be added for Poll #2: Carter O'Callaghan/Jordin FourFour

Also, ArGarBarGar, I know it hasn't been updated in a while, but whenever you get around to it, I'm listed in that file twice lol

Oh jeez.

I removed the duplicate in the word file.

Woo.

--------------------
The Road Lead All Defensemen:
Goals | 6th (7 to 5th)
Assists | 2nd (42 to 1st)
Hits | 2nd (1021 to 1st)
Blocked Shots | All Time Blocked Shots Leader (1324)
Points | 2nd (84 to 1st)
user posted image
"League of Accomplished Players"
Player Profile | Update Thread
.pm   
^
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:
Share this topic:
« Next Oldest | SHL Discussion | Next Newest »

.options    Pages: (10) 1 2 3 ... Last » .reply    .quick reply    .new topic    .new poll